A Responsive Reader

In my last post I shared what I learned from Lucy Grealy‘s Autobiography of a FaceReading that book was not one of my best “moments.”

Not long after I read that book and experienced the feeling that I didn’t completely connect, I read a companion work. Truth & Beauty, by Ann Patchett, is a memoir reflecting on the writer’s friendship with Lucy Grealy.

I fell into this book completely.  No reservations at all. And it did make me wonder if Grealy’s very difficult personality (personality disorder? and addictions) weren’t something that I picked up on and made me wary when I read Autobiography of a Face. It will be hard to go back and re-read that book as if I don’t know the extent of her “use and abuse” of Patchett.

Then, again, this book is Patchett’s version. Grealy is gone and can’t comment on it. She can’t write a “response memoir.” So why am I so willing to believe Patchett’s version, but hold myself at a distance from Grealy’s version of what is, in essence, her self?

Oh, this memoir business is a tough business.

What did I learn from this book? That the hard truth can be presented in beauty if it is accompanied by compassion.

###

Here’s a thought. I suspect I didn’t like Grealy from reading her book. The question would be: why not? Maybe it was her lack of compassion for others. I just didn’t see any at all. Would that be because she was born with a personality incapable of feeling compassion? Or would it be a learned response to life, based on her difficulties?

It’s easy to see why Patchett and Grealy were friends. Patchett had enough compassion for them both.

13 Comments

Filed under Book Review, Books, Creative Nonfiction, Essay, Memoir, Nonfiction, Research and prep for writing, Writing

13 responses to “A Responsive Reader

  1. You have described two books that present a sad, curious situation — a human mystery without an answer.

  2. This entry and the previous one sound fascinating! Might be worth it to read them both.

  3. This is so interesting, Luanne. Having never read either book, this post makes me want to read Truth & Beauty. My question is, can I read T&B without reading Lucy’s story?

  4. Fascinating comparison of the two books and the two personaities…
    (Book in mail to you, Luanne! )

  5. Such an interesting comparison. Now that I’ve seen through your writing how often our histories and tastes have paralleled, I am quite sure if YOU don’t like Grealy I certainly would not!

    • Luanne

      Shel, that’s certainly a fascinating theory–that our lives have paralleled so much that you wouldn’t like Grealy either. Haha, I actually did think at one point: I wonder what Shel would make of her. Isn’t that something?

  6. Oh, my, another book to read 😉 Thanks, Luanne!

  7. Pingback: Not a Model Memoir, But a Darn Good Read | Writer Site

I'd love to hear your comments

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s